Welcome to New York New York Pizza
New York New York Pizza, located on Dale Mabry Hwy in Tampa, delivers an authentic pizza experience that resonates with customers. With rave reviews highlighting its perfectly crispy thin crust and flavorful toppings, diners can expect dishes like the classic cheese and pepperoni and their renowned grandma pie. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, complemented by exceptional service from staff like Wendy, who ensures each guest feels welcomed. Patrons consistently describe their meals as unforgettable, packed with freshness and charm. This pizza haven not only offers great food but fosters a sense of community, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
New York New York Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
This pizza is the ABSOLUTE BEST in the Bay Area my family and I didn’t stop talking about the taste, so we absolutely came back the next day. The vibes inside is so chill and homey, the music is great and Wendy is so welcoming and loving. We’re going to be regulars here
I’ve been coming here for almost 8 years and I finally went back after a year not going due to moving to a different city. Every time I visit I have to come here and today the pizza was amazing. Met the manager and they showed me love with open arms and their pizza just keeps getting better every time I come here. The classic cheese and pepperoni is the best but I also highly recommend grandma pie. No one does that better than them guarantee!! Thank you and always love. One of the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life and I’m from New York and very picky with pizza. The best
We had an absolutely amazing experience at this pizza restaurant! From the moment we walked in, the service was exceptional. Wendy went above and beyond—she not only provided excellent recommendations but also remembered our dietary restrictions, which made the experience even more special. The food was incredible, and her Sicilian suggestions were out of this world! Every bite was packed with flavor, and you could truly taste the authenticity. It’s rare to find a place that combines great food with such outstanding hospitality. I’ll definitely continue being a regular. I will highly recommend this spot to anyone looking for a top-tier pizza experience! - Abe & Gabe
This food was so good. Perfect well done crust where the slice doesn’t bend under the weight of the toppings(which were nicely spread over the whole pie). Best fried mushrooms I’ve had in a long time. Stayed crispy on the drive home, plump mushroom in the middle; I’ll go back for those alone lol. Wish I took a better pic but we just dove in.
100% the best place in Tampa to get pizza. All of their locations are great. Perfectly crispy thin crust, fresh mozzarella and basil, slightly sweet sauce... I'm a pizza snob and this is truly awesome pizza.
This pizza place is absolutely the best I ever had. From the moment you walk in and the staff is amazing. You can smell the pizza just coming out of the oven. The taste is delish and so fresh I highly recommend for you to try it and you won’t be disappointed. You guys are my favorite.
Ordered online, quick and easy. Love coming to Florida for NY pizza because it’s authentic, probably because of all the NY’s who migrate south. Food was great, smelled great in the car! Was not greasy! Staff was great.
We just moved to the area, and are so happy to find a place that makes real NY style pizza. The ingredients were fresh, and the combination of them on the half and half pie was great and delicious. On top of that, Wendy made the experience even greater with her awesome customer service and charm. She went through the menu, and offered me various options and tips, making the ordering process a smooth one. I totally recommend this place. You won't be disappointed.
Location
-
10434 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618, United States Hotline: +1 813-443-4598
Welcome to **New York New York Pizza**, a beloved gem nestled at 10434 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL. This pizzeria is not just another eatery; it’s a culinary experience that transports you straight to the heart of New York City with every bite.
As you step inside, you are enveloped by a chill, homey atmosphere enhanced by delightful music rhythms, creating an inviting ambiance that instantly makes you feel at home. Customers rave about the exceptional service, especially from the ever-friendly Wendy, whose warm hospitality transforms an ordinary meal into a cherished memory.
The highlight of the menu is undoubtedly their pizza. Renowned for its crispy thin crust and perfectly balanced toppings, each slice is an ode to authentic New York-style pizza. Reviewers like Deanna McKeithen have hailed it as the best pizza spot in Tampa, praising the fresh mozzarella, fragrant basil, and a slightly sweet sauce that ties everything together.
Kristen Casillas, another ecstatic patron, highlighted that the flavors linger long after the meal is finished, making it impossible to stay away for long.
If you’re seeking recommendations, the classic cheese and pepperoni pizza is a must-try, as noted by longtime customer Jose Velez, who emphasizes its consistent quality over the years. Adventurous diners may opt for the grandma pie, a unique take that guarantees satisfaction. Each bite is crafted with fresh ingredients that deliver an explosion of flavors, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to authenticity and excellence.
Beyond pizza, guests cannot overlook the fried mushrooms, which Jess W claims are the best she’s had in ages; crispy and perfectly cooked, they are undeniably worthy of a separate trip!
In addition to remarkable food, the overall dining experience is enriched by the genuine care shown by the staff. Customers like Huncho Jean-Simon have shared their appreciation for the team's attentiveness, especially with dietary needs, ensuring that every visit is tailored and memorable.
In summary, **New York New York Pizza** offers more than just food; it provides a community hub where flavor, service, and a welcoming spirit converge. Whether you're a local or a visitor, a slice of their pizza is a must—because once you’ve tasted it, you’ll understand why so many people describe it as a slice of New York heaven. Don't miss out on this delightful dining experience—give them a call at +1 813-443-4598 and prepare for your new favorite pizza destination!